Kiely and Rob wore matching "his and hers" pink saddle shoes for their wedding. But no matter if it's a "his and hers" or "hers and hers" or "his and his" situation, wearing matching Chucks, Toms, creepers, Oxfords, flip flops, heels, flats etc., would be a sweet little detail. (Psst: It looks like Kiely is wearing Rachel Antonoff for Bass' "Saddled with Sweetness Heel" — the pink has sold out, but it's available in black and white polka dots! I can't pin down Rob's shoes though.)
The point is, matching shoes are ADORBZ.